Emilie M. Townes
Spring Faculty Assembly Presentation
Delivered 1 April 2021
download a PDF of this presentation with its original formatting.
perhaps you are familiar with this childhood chant: sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me
i remember my teachers, grandmother, parents, aunts, and other mothers teaching it to us when we were growing up
in that small transclass black southern community that i called home in my youth
i also remember using it as a retort to playmates who sometimes turned cruel or indifferent or worse dismissive
it was only as i grew older and understood the power of words that i no longer used this retort because it was not true
i experienced the some-time anguish of being called out of my name (as the old folks used to say)
of being labeled ugly or gay or too smart or naïve
and having to dig deep into other resources my parents and other loving adults put in me to say no and not be fooled into self-hatred
the other day, i recalled this old adage when it was used in a senior paper i was reading and preparing for the student’s oral defense
hmmmm…why did the older adults in my life teach us little black kids this adage with such universal vigor
they had to know that we would figure it out as we grew older and experienced more in life and living
i do not think it coincidental that one of the earliest, if not the earliest citation of it is from a US religious periodical that had a largely black audience, The Christian Recorder of March 1862, though i suspect its origin is much earlier than this
it was deployed to help express indifference to verbal insult while reckoning with the dangers of physical abuse or violence
this verbal signification was a way to preserve the inner person
that which would help folk tolerate whatever verbal insult or name-calling that came their way so that they could possibly survive the some-time deadly assault on black lives
but from our 2021 perch, this can appear to be a rather thin defense against systematic “isms” that have been woven into the threads of our lives and scholarship and sometimes enters our classrooms
to say that hurtful words may not cause physical pain and because they do not, one should ignore or disregard them
rings as trite with all we know about the way that language functions in our ego and psyche to begin to wither us from within
and can create hollowed out methods and musings that may be interesting but fail to address the rich excitement of living and the challenges we face in the academy and society to help translate our work into vibrant and public conversations interested in truth-telling
rather than swapping misguided bromides of power in verbal and physical minefields
as a sometimes grumpy social ethicist, i have an investment in the systems and structures that shape us as we shape them to be just and to try to suss out what we mean by powerful notions such as “the common good” or “academic freedom”
and then it came to me: this old adage was a holding pattern for us
it gave little black kids like me a chance to gain some thickness to our skin
some confidence in our worth
some time to believe we were just as much a gift to the rest of creation as anyone else
so that when the name calling came—we could catch it and deflect it
and if safe to do so—call out the lie and the constellation of stereotypes and caricatures that hold that lie in place
much of my work over these last several years has been exploring the nature of stereotypes that demean and draw what i think of as hellish caricatures of black folk, particularly black women and children
aunt jemima
sapphire
welfare queen
tragic mulatta
pickaninny
these names and others that call Asian groups, indigenous groups, ethnicities, nationalities, citizenships, genders, sexualities and more out of their name are meant to define, categorize, commodify and dismiss the complexity of lives that we often do not know, but have glimpses of
and assume that the glimpse is exhaustive
these negative, demeaning caricatures/stereotypes and other stereotypes based on other races and ethnicities, genders, nationalities, sexual orientations, age, political persuasions, religious beliefs, theologies are products of our imagination gone wrong
what i term the fantastic hegemonic imagination—drawing on Foucault’s fantastic and Gramsci’s hegemony melded by womanist social ethical methodology and analysis
in short, the fantastic hegemonic imagination traffics in peoples’ lives that are caricatured or pillaged so that the imagination that creates the fantastic can control the world in its own image
if we say it enough, even when not true, we begin to think it accurate and representative and ultimately fact
the caricature moves from simplification and exaggeration to policy and religious tenets or in the case of aunt jemima—to pancake, waffle, and cornmeal mixes, grits, and syrup
she was not a historical figure—house slaves were, for the most part, mulatta or quadroon—not dark-skinned
they were not fat—even though working in the plantation house, servants were not guaranteed an abundance of food, so few were stout
but the minstrel shows of the late 1800s began to conjure her up for laughs and entertainment
she was the creation of the white imagination that began appearing in post-civil war magazines imagining a bucolic south that never existed
and from the moment she was introduced by the Pearl Milling Company of St Joseph, MO in 1888 for the first commercial pancake mix, black folk and allies protested her existence because she was not accurate nor true
finally, Quaker has announced that it will remove the Aunt Jemima icon—who did go through several iterations—from its packaging and change the name of the brand in 2020
now going back to its original name, Pearl Milling Company, this summer she will finally be gone from the packaging
but she lingers
one of the things about words is that they often conjure up images
and the images created in the fantastic hegemonic imagination are no respecter of race or gender or any of the many ways we realize our living in our great diversity
words can harm but they can also heal
and this is where we in the academy can be helpful, if not necessary as we engage in putting the knowledge we have into public spaces and are constantly learning to help create a democracy that we can live in
that welcomes the diversity of what it means to be in this big tent republic of ours with all of the highest aspirations we have
from Winthrop’s city on a hill
to Hoover’s chicken in every pot
to Roosevelt’s happy days are here again
to Eisenhower’s peace and prosperity
to Haaland’s only one earth, let’s take care of it
to Amanda Gorman who reminded us
When day comes we step out of the shade,
aflame and unafraid,
the new dawn blooms as we free it.
For there is always light,
if only we’re brave enough to see it.
If only we’re brave enough to be it.
Thank you for your attention